PostHog vs Microsoft Clarity vs Hotjar (2026): Free Session Replay, Pricing, and Consent
Microsoft Clarity, PostHog, and Hotjar (now Contentsquare) all record sessions, but they bill, retain data, and handle consent very differently. Here is what each costs for a 50,000-session small-business site, from each vendor's own pricing pages.
The short answer
Use Microsoft Clarity if you want free session replay and heatmaps. It costs $0, has no traffic limits, and keeps recordings for 30 days. Choose PostHog if you also need product analytics, feature flags, or replay retention beyond 30 days (90 days on pay-as-you-go): 5,000 recordings and 1 million events are free each month, then replay costs $0.0050 per recording. Hotjar is now Contentsquare, so new sign-ups go to Contentsquare, where paid plans start at $49 a month.
What each tool actually is in 2026
Microsoft Clarity is a behavior analytics tool: session recordings, heatmaps, and Microsoft's "Copilot in Clarity" AI summaries. Microsoft's FAQ states: "Clarity is 100% free - forever. You're never asked to upgrade to a paid version." There is no sampling, but there is a ceiling: Clarity "records up to 100,000 sessions per project per day."
PostHog is a product analytics suite. Session replay is one product alongside event analytics, feature flags, experiments, surveys, and error tracking. Each product is billed by usage, and each has its own monthly free allowance. PostHog says the allowance "resets monthly" and is the "same allowance whether or not you have a card on file."
Hotjar no longer takes new customers under its own name. hotjar.com redirects to a Contentsquare page headed "Hotjar is now Contentsquare," which says "It's no longer possible to create a new account on Hotjar." Existing Hotjar users log in with the same credentials, and hotjar.com/pricing redirects to Contentsquare's pricing page. Functionally, the closest match to the old Hotjar Observe product is Contentsquare's Experience Analytics plan (replays, heatmaps, and funnels). Contentsquare does not publish an official plan mapping. Surveys and feedback widgets sit in a separate Voice of Customer plan.
Mixpanel comes up in the same searches. It is mainly event-based product analytics, and its Free plan includes up to 1 million events and 10,000 session replays a month.
Pricing side by side
Prices and plan names are as published on each vendor's own pricing page; last verified 10 November 2026.
| Vendor | Billing unit | Published entry price | What it's for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Microsoft Clarity | None (free) | $0, no paid tier | Heatmaps, session recordings, AI summaries of recordings and heatmaps |
| PostHog | Per recording (replay), per event (analytics) | $0 up to 5,000 recordings and 1M events a month; then from $0.0050 per recording and from $0.00005 per anonymous event ($0.000198 per identified event), cheaper at volume | Product analytics, replay, feature flags, and experiments in one tool |
| Contentsquare Experience Analytics (formerly Hotjar) | Monthly sessions, in tiers | Free: 200k sessions, 5% of sessions captured as replays (max 10k). Growth: $49/month for 7k sessions billed monthly, $39 billed yearly | Heatmaps, replays, funnels, error monitoring |
| Mixpanel | Events | Free: up to 1M events and 10K session replays a month | Event-based product analytics with replay attached |
PostHog's replay price drops at each volume step: $0.0050 per recording from 5k to 15k, $0.0035 from 15k to 50k, $0.0020 from 50k to 150k, $0.0017 from 150k to 500k, and $0.0015 above that. Mobile recordings are billed separately. They get 2,500 free a month, then start at $0.0100 each.
Worked example: a 50,000-session small-business site
Assumptions: 50,000 web sessions a month, all from the US, so no consent banner reduces capture. About 15 analytics events per session, which is 750,000 events a month. We want a replay for every session where the tool allows it.
Microsoft Clarity: $0 a month. 50,000 sessions a month averages about 1,700 a day, far below the 100,000-per-day cap. Every session is recorded. Recordings are deleted after 30 days unless they are favorited.
PostHog: $172.50 a month if you record everything.
- Events: 750,000 is under the 1,000,000 free allowance, so $0.
- Replay: the first 5,000 recordings are free. The next 10,000 (5k to 15k) cost $0.0050 each, which is $50.00. The remaining 35,000 (15k to 50k) cost $0.0035 each, which is $122.50.
- Total: $0 + $50.00 + $122.50 = $172.50.
- PostHog's recording controls let you sample a percentage of sessions, record only on certain URLs or events, and drop sessions below a minimum duration. Sampling 20% gives 10,000 recordings. The first 5,000 are free and the other 5,000 cost $0.0050 each, so the bill is $25.00. You can also set a billing limit, and PostHog says it will "stop ingesting recordings when you reach your limit."
Contentsquare (Hotjar's successor): $0 on Free, or $279 a month on Growth.
- Free covers up to 200k monthly sessions, but only 5% of sessions are captured as replays, with a maximum of 10k. 5% of 50,000 is 2,500 replays. Data access is limited to one month.
- Growth has no 50k tier. The nearest tiers are 45k ($219 a month) and 60k ($279 a month, billed monthly). At 50,000 sessions you need the 60k tier, which the page lists "with 20k replays". Growth replay capture is "15% sessions captured (min. 20k)", so at 50,000 sessions you get about 20,000 replays, or 40% of sessions. Billed yearly, the page lists the 60k tier at $223 a month.
Mixpanel: $0 a month. 750,000 events fits under the Free plan's 1 million, and the Free plan includes 10K session replays a month. That covers a fifth of the 50,000 sessions.
What the example shows: for pure "watch what visitors do" use, Clarity wins on cost, and it is not close. PostHog's price only makes sense if you will use its analytics, flags, or experiments. Contentsquare's free tier is generous on sessions but thin on replays, and Growth replays about 40% of sessions at this size.
Get one new AI workflow every week
Practical playbooks, prompts, and tool stacks — for the SMB operators and enterprise teams actually shipping AI.
Consent and data residency
This section is where the tools differ most once you have visitors from Europe.
Clarity. Microsoft states: "Starting October 31, 2025, Clarity begins enforcing consent signal requirements for page visits originating from the European Economic Area (EEA), United Kingdom (UK), and Switzerland (CH)." Consent Mode is on by default for those visitors. If consent is not granted, Clarity "assigns a unique ID per page view and does not use cookies to persist session data." Microsoft's FAQ adds that "to use Clarity's full feature set including session recordings and behavioral analytics, valid consent is required" in those regions. You pass consent through a supported consent management platform (CookieYes is named) or by calling clarity('consentv2', ...). If you have no EEA, UK, or Swiss traffic, Microsoft says there is no impact. Data is stored in Microsoft Azure. EU customers contract with Microsoft Ireland Operations Limited.
PostHog. PostHog's GDPR guidance says to use "a cookie banner to enable people to give and withdraw their consent for using cookies." It offers cookieless_mode: "always", which never stores data in cookies or local storage and counts users with a server-side privacy-preserving hash. It also offers "on_reject", which waits for the banner decision. In the default setup, PostHog does not check consent itself. Your cookie banner has to call PostHog's opt-in and opt-out methods. Cookieless mode has a trade-off, listed in PostHog's own docs: "Session replay and surveys: Both are disabled if the user has not given cookie consent." You choose US (Virginia) or EU (Frankfurt) hosting when you sign up.
Contentsquare. In a 2022 privacy-center article, written around the then-pending EU ePrivacy Regulation, Contentsquare argued that its first-party audience measurement "should be exempted from visitor's prior consent." Its own country table shows that exemption does not apply in Germany, Spain, or the UK. A "Cookieless" option moves its identifiers into browser localStorage and sessionStorage instead of cookies. Ask your privacy counsel whether that changes your banner requirements. The pricing page does not say where data is hosted, so ask before you sign.
Mixpanel lists "US or EU data residency." You choose it when you create a project, and it is not on by default.
AI features each vendor publishes
- Clarity Copilot (no charge, like the rest of Clarity): Session Insights summarizes one recording, Grouped Session Insights summarizes several at once, and Heatmap Insights summarizes a page's heatmaps. There is also a chat over your dashboard data. Microsoft's limits: Session Insights skip sessions under five seconds and do not support mobile apps. Microsoft's FAQ says Copilot "takeaways … shouldn't be treated as expert recommendations."
- PostHog includes AI credits in the free tier: "Replay Vision 2500 credits (worth $25)" and "PostHog AI 500 credits (worth $5)" each month.
- Contentsquare lists Session Replay Summaries as "Not included" on Free, "Single Session" on Growth, and "Multiple Sessions" on Pro and Enterprise.
When not to use each tool
When not to use Microsoft Clarity
- You need recordings older than 30 days. Only favorites and a random sample are kept for up to 9 months.
- You need identified-user funnels, feature flags, or A/B tests in the same tool.
- A single heatmap is "limited to up to 100,000 page views," and recording stops at 100,000 sessions per project per day.
- Your contracts restrict who can access visitor data. Microsoft's FAQ says plainly that "Microsoft/Clarity has access to the data," under Clarity's terms of use.
When not to use PostHog
- You only want heatmaps for a marketing site. You would be paying per recording for something Clarity does for free.
- Most of your traffic is short bounce sessions. Every recorded session counts toward the bill unless you set a minimum duration or sampling.
- You need long replay history on a small budget. Recordings are kept for 1 month on the free plan and 90 days on pay-as-you-go. Longer retention requires the Boost, Scale, or Enterprise add-ons.
When not to use Contentsquare (Hotjar)
- You expect traffic spikes. Growth is a hard cap: "once you reach the monthly sessions purchased on our Growth plans, you won't be able to get more session data before the next month."
- You need every session replayable. Growth replays are "15% sessions captured (min. 20k)". The 60k tier includes 20k replays, so a 50,000-session site replays about 40% of visits.
- You need to confirm EU data hosting before signing. The pricing page does not state it.
When not to use Mixpanel
- Your question is "where do people click on this page?" Heatmaps are Clarity's and Contentsquare's core job, not Mixpanel's.
Frequently asked questions
Is Microsoft Clarity really free?
Yes. Microsoft's FAQ says Clarity is "100% free - forever" with no paid version and no traffic limits. The practical limits are 100,000 recorded sessions per project per day and 30-day retention for recordings that are not favorited.
Is Hotjar still available in 2026?
Not for new customers under the Hotjar name. Hotjar's site says "Hotjar is now Contentsquare" and "It's no longer possible to create a new account on Hotjar." Existing users can still log in, and new users sign up on Contentsquare, whose Experience Analytics Growth plan starts at $49 a month billed monthly.
How much does PostHog session replay cost?
The first 5,000 web recordings each month are free. After that, the price is $0.0050 per recording up to 15,000, falling to $0.0035, $0.0020, $0.0017, and $0.0015 at higher volumes. Recording all 50,000 sessions of a 50,000-session site costs $172.50 a month.
Do I need a cookie banner for Microsoft Clarity?
Since October 31, 2025, Clarity needs a valid consent signal for EEA, UK, or Swiss visitors to record full sessions. The signal comes from a supported consent platform such as CookieYes, or from Clarity's consentv2 API; without one, it runs in a limited no-cookie mode. Whether you legally need a banner is a question for your privacy counsel.
Microsoft Clarity or PostHog: which is better for a small business?
Clarity is the better choice if you only need replay and heatmaps, because it costs nothing at any traffic level. PostHog is the better choice when you also need product analytics, feature flags, or experiments, and its free allowances cover many small sites.
Does PostHog record sessions without cookie consent?
Not if you turn on its cookieless mode. PostHog's docs say that in cookieless mode, session replay and surveys "are disabled if the user has not given cookie consent," while visitors are still counted with a privacy-preserving hash. In the default setup PostHog does not check consent itself, so your cookie banner has to call PostHog's opt-in and opt-out methods.
Next step
Read the head-to-head Microsoft Clarity vs PostHog or Hotjar vs Microsoft Clarity comparisons, or browse every option in the analytics tools category.
Related Workflows
Browser-Using Agent for Vendor Research & Pricing Sweeps
Agentic browser session that visits 50 vendor sites, captures pricing, terms, and feature differences, and produces a comparison sheet — overnight.
View workflowPredictive Maintenance Alerting
Monitor equipment sensor data and production metrics to predict failures before they happen — reducing downtime and emergency repair costs.
View workflowAI Receptionist & Virtual Front Desk
Handle inbound calls and website inquiries 24/7 with an AI receptionist that books appointments, answers FAQs, and routes urgent requests.
View workflowKeep Reading
Langfuse vs LangSmith vs Braintrust (and PostHog): LLM Observability Pricing 2026
The six LLM observability tools buyers compare most, priced from each vendor's own pricing page, with a worked monthly bill at 300,000 traces and a five-person team.
Vagaro vs Fresha vs GlossGenius vs Boulevard (2026): Real Monthly Cost for a 4-Chair Salon
Subscription price is the smallest line on a salon software bill. This comparison prices Vagaro, Fresha, GlossGenius, and Boulevard for a 4-chair salon processing $30,000 a month, using each vendor's own published rates.
Pinecone vs Weaviate vs Qdrant vs Milvus (and pgvector): Vector Database Pricing 2026
Seven vector database options priced from each vendor's own pricing page and docs, with a worked monthly bill for one million 1,536-dimension vectors and when plain pgvector is the right answer.
Found this helpful?
Get weekly AI workflow ideas in your inbox.